Sparing the Rod without Spoiling the Child(b)

Chou explains that in the face of rapid change, when the student-teacher­ relationship is being thoroughly reformulated, Taiwan's teacher training is still stuck in a traditional paradigm that stresses academic subjects and gives short shrift to cultivating professional ethics. Moreover, teachers who weren't education majors and who have only taken a streamlined education curriculum lack even more communicative skills needed for the life coach side of teaching. Dealing with increasingly difficult and disrespectful students, they may end up beating and scolding students because they lack any other strategies.


"A big problem is that Taiwan's parents are still beating their children," notes the National Teachers' Association's Chan Cheng-tao. "The law only prohibits teachers from beating children." In school, the treatment is much more lax, and that disparity could lead to children playing goody-goody at home and then releasing their pent-up emotions in the classroom. The children may sense correctly that teachers dare not act against them, so they act up. Even if they've been warned, these students may simply not care, making them impossible to discipline or get through to. Stricter teachers, who believe that they wouldn't be doing their duties as teachers if they were too lax, have often been regarded by students as unreasonable and out of step with the times.


In an age when teachers have lost their sticks and now only hold carrots, what educational methods can be crafted so that a lack of discipline doesn't end up constituting a triple loss for parents, teachers, and students? It's an assignment that will test the wisdom not only of teachers but also of parents, schools, and society as a whole.


  周祝瑛解释,面对环境快速变迁、师生关系大洗牌的时代,台湾师资培育却仍停留在『只重学科』的传统观念上,忽视专业伦理的养成。而非教育科系出身,仅透过教育学程、短时间培养出来的师资,更缺乏『人师』亟需的沟通互动能力。面对愈来愈刁钻、愈来愈不尊师重道的学生,无计可施下,似乎也只有体罚与责骂一途了。


  『有个很大的问题是:台湾的家长仍在打孩子,却只立法要求老师不准体罚,』全国教师会政策部主任詹政道表示。到了学校,孩子受到的『待遇』宽松许多,这种错乱,导致一些孩子可能在家里『装乖』,却把压抑的情绪带到课堂。他们看准老师『不敢』动手而恣意喧闹,就算警告记过,学生也似乎毫不在乎,使得管教或让这些小孩明事理更显困难。秉持着『教不严,师之惰』精神的严格老师们,往往被认为不通情理、与时代脱节而被排拒。


  当严师失去了棒子,手中只有胡萝卜时,究竟该如何琢磨出一套新时代的教养方法,才不致沦为亲、师、生『三输』?这不只考验着老师,更是家长、校方、社会共同的功课。


本社为尊重《台湾光华杂志》,中文原文注销,仅供参考,中英文如有不尽相符之处,敬请包涵。





0

播放音频

Sparing the Rod without Spoiling the Child(b)

开心一读